Sunday, November 6, 2016

Weekly Playoff Probabilities - Week 10

As always, explanation here, ranking below, thoughts after.
 
Rank Team Agg Rank POFF Prob Change
1 Alabama 2 97.61% 3.1%
2 Clemson 5 95.28% -0.9%
3 Michigan 1 79.74% 0.8%
4 Washington 6 48.17% 3.9%
5 Ohio State 3 42.84% 8.5%
6 Louisville 4 13.97% 0.8%
7 Western Michigan 19 12.36% 1.0%
8 Auburn 7 2.46% 0.9%
9 Texas A&M 9 2.01% -15.3%
10 West Virginia 24 1.67% 0.2%
11 Penn State 15 1.04% 0.4%
12 Colorado 11 0.94% 0.3%
13 Wisconsin 13 0.76% 0.0%
14 Oklahoma 12 0.62% 0.1%
15 North Carolina 18 0.16% 0.1%
16 Nebraska 37 0.14% -0.2%
17 Washington State 16 0.13% 0.1%
18 Oklahoma State 25 0.06% 0.0%
19 Virginia Tech 21 0.02% 0.0%
20 Utah 35 0.01% 0.0%
21 Baylor 30 0.00% -0.5%
22 Florida 22 0.00% -0.4%
23 Minnesota 47 0.00% 0.0%

1.  Very little changed at the top this week, other than Bama moving up to #1 after passing a test, and A&M falling down after failing a test.   Unless something weird happens, 4 of the current top 6 are going to be in playoff.  This is a little more boring than last year, but 1) it's the truth and 2) the playoff itself should be awesome.

2.  This is a little further down the rankings, but it's a fun effect of conference title games.  Virginia Tech and North Carolina are roughly equal teams with similar remaining schedules.  Yet, UNC is about 8 times more likely to make the playoff than the Hokies.  The reason for this is that VT is much more likely to win the division and have to play Clemson, which means they are far less likely to finish with just two losses.  In reality, the committee may not punish conference title losses as much as other losses, but it's still an interesting display of how my model works.
 
3.  We say goodbye to just one team this week: LSU.  The Tigers are the best team eliminated yet (8th in the composite ratings), but it was clear that offense wasn't getting fixed enough to compete at the highest level, this year at least.
 
4.  The conference race stays basically the same, too.  If someone's getting two teams in, it's the Big Ten, as A&M can no longer be an 11-1 runner up in the SEC West:

Conference Exp Playoff Teams
B10 1.245
ACC 1.094
SEC 1.021
P12 0.492
MAC 0.124
B12 0.024
 
5.  Congrats to San Diego State on becoming the first team to clinch their division.  While the Aztecs are good, it helps to be in the worst division possible.  In other news, there are still five teams with a chance to win the terrible SEC East, and the team currently in fifth place (Tennessee) nearly has the best odds of doing so.  Finally, the ACC Atlantic is almost certainly the most humorous race.  In my 10,000 simulations, Clemson won the division 9,959 times.  Another 40 times, Clemson lost both their remaining games, and Louisville took the division.  And in one bizarre timeline, Wake Forest became the team of destiny and won the division themselves by sweeping two top five teams.

Conference Favorite Perc   Runner-Up Perc
ACCA Clemson 99.6%   Louisville 0.4%
ACCC Virginia Tech 83.9%   North Carolina 16.1%
AMEE Temple 88.5%   South Florida 10.7%
AMEW Navy 43.5%   Tulsa 38.2%
B10E Michigan 65.6%   Ohio State 22.7%
B10W Wisconsin 83.7%   Nebraska 9.1%
B12 Oklahoma 67.4%   West Virginia 16.7%
CUSAE Western Kentucky 90.8%   Old Dominion 7.7%
CUSAW Louisiana Tech 83.0%   UTSA 9.9%
MACE Ohio 88.0%   Miami (OH) 8.7%
MACW Western Michigan 85.2%   Toledo 14.8%
MWCE San Diego State 100.0%      
MWCM Wyoming 58.2%   Boise State 36.2%
P12N Washington 72.6%   Washington State 27.4%
P12S Colorado 80.5%   Utah 11.1%
SECE Florida 50.8%   Tennessee 46.6%
SECW Alabama 84.9%   Auburn 15.1%
SUN Troy 44.4%   Appalachian State 43.8%


Week 11 Preview

Home Away Home Win Prob Playoff Teams Lost
Washington USC 78.3% 0.036
Clemson Pitt 92.1% 0.026
Iowa Michigan 6.5% 0.018
Maryland Ohio State 4.5% 0.010
Alabama Mississippi State 97.2% 0.009
Texas A&M Ole Miss 66.6% 0.007
Texas West Virginia 46.7% 0.004
Georgia Auburn 13.9% 0.004
Kent State Western Michigan 7.4% 0.003
Louisville Wake Forest 96.7% 0.002

The next two weeks certainly have games worth watching, but there's not much punch at the top when compared to past weeks.  Washington-USC should be an entertaining game, but there's little else involving the top teams that is likely to be competitive.  If we're looking further down the list, Minnesota-Nebraska, Oklahoma-Baylor, and App State-Troy are all interesting games that will have impacts on things other than the playoff field.

No comments:

Post a Comment