Saturday, September 5, 2020

College Football Playoff Predictor - Year 6

If you're already aware of the wide range of ideology within college football punditry, then the last six months have probably not surprised you.  A sport that's proud to profit off the labor of unpaid athletes has enlisted plenty of cheerleaders happy to carry water for those in charge.  And carry water they have, to the point of basically denying that there is even a pandemic happening in the first place.  On the less buffoonish side of the spectrum, there have been two lines of thought.  One is that there's no way a season will work and everything will be shut down post haste.  The other (the view I've held) is that everyone is too addicted to money to not push ahead full steam, even if y'know, people die.  As it turns out the ultimate answer was right in the middle. 

What this means is we now have a weird Frankenstein of a season on our hands.  I'm not particularly enthused about it, and considered taking a year off from the spreadsheets.  But the one thing that convinced me to push through is the high probability of chaos.  There will never be a better chance to get a 2-loss team or a Group of Five team into the Playoff.  Maybe there will even be a three-loss team in contention that will completely destroy my model.  So push on we must. 


The Model

In spite of the weirdness of this season, my model is the same as previous years.  If this year breaks it, no biggie.  Here is my most recent primer if you care about such things.  I have eliminated Air Force and their two-game schedule, and Southern Miss already lost so they're out as well.

Rank Team Agg Rank CFP Prob
1  Clemson 2 87.35%
2  Alabama 1 71.15%
3  Oklahoma 4 53.53%
4  Notre Dame 9 24.79%
5  Georgia 3 24.10%
6  Texas 8 23.13%
7  Auburn 5 19.40%
8  Florida 6 17.23%
9  LSU 7 14.68%
10  Oklahoma State 12 9.92%
11  Louisville 16 7.74%
12  Texas A&M 10 7.03%
13  North Carolina 18 6.07%
14  Central Florida 11 5.46%
15  Virginia Tech 17 4.83%
16  TCU 13 4.64%
17  Iowa State 14 4.29%
18  Florida State 15 4.24%
19  Appalachian State 26 2.97%
20  Baylor 20 1.92%
21  BYU 39 1.20%
22  Miami (FL) 28 0.95%
23  Memphis 22 0.63%
24  Cincinnati 25 0.32%
25  Marshall 52 0.28%
26  Kentucky 19 0.28%
27  Kansas State 27 0.26%
28  Pitt 31 0.22%
29  Tennessee 21 0.18%
30  Texas Tech 29 0.17%
31  Virginia 36 0.15%
32  Florida Atlantic 49 0.14%
33  West Virginia 33 0.10%
34  South Carolina 23 0.10%
35  Louisiana-Lafayette 38 0.09%
36  Duke 41 0.09%
37  Ole Miss 24 0.08%
38  North Carolina State 44 0.08%
39  UAB 51 0.05%
40  Georgia Tech 35 0.04%
41  Boston College 42 0.02%
42  Wake Forest 43 0.02%
43  Georgia Southern 54 0.02%
44  Western Kentucky 50 0.02%
45  Navy 37 0.01%
46  Houston 34 0.01%
47  Army 57 0.01%
48  Louisiana Tech 58 0.01%
49  Mississippi State 32 0.00%
50  Troy 59 0.00%
51  Rice 73 0.00%
52  Florida International 70 0.00%
53  Coastal Carolina 63 0.00%
54  North Texas 68 0.00%
55  Syracuse 55 0.00%
56  SMU 40 0.00%
57  Arkansas 45 0.00%
58  South Florida 56 0.00%
59  Vanderbilt 61 0.00%
60  Kansas 64 0.00%
61  Tulsa 48 0.00%
62  Tulane 46 0.00%
63  Missouri 30 0.00%
64  East Carolina 65 0.00%
65  Georgia State 66 0.00%
66  Arkansas State 60 0.00%
67  South Alabama 71 0.00%
68  Temple 53 0.00%
69  Louisiana-Monroe 74 0.00%
70  UTSA 75 0.00%
71  Middle Tennessee 72 0.00%
72  Texas State 76 0.00%
73  UTEP 77 0.00%
74  Charlotte 69 0.00%
75  Liberty 67 0.00%

I normally spend some time in this post going through the best games of every week, but the schedule isn't that deep and all of the September weekends are butt.  So let's just take a look at the best games of the year.  Pretty good conference matchup at the top if you ask me.

Week Home Away Home Win Prob Playoff Teams Lost
10 Notre Dame Clemson 25.6% 0.136
7 Alabama Georgia 74.2% 0.121
6 Texas Oklahoma 39.5% 0.118
11 LSU Alabama 29.4% 0.105
13 Alabama Auburn 79.4% 0.101
5 Georgia Auburn 64.0% 0.071
12 Oklahoma Oklahoma State 75.5% 0.069
10 Georgia Florida 58.7% 0.067
8 TCU Oklahoma 28.5% 0.062
5 Iowa State Oklahoma 27.7% 0.060

I also typically break down all the conference races, but once again I cannot bring myself to care.  But the ACC probabilities are pretty funny so here are those.