Sunday, September 29, 2019

Weekly Playoff Probabilities - Week 5

As always, explanation here, ranking below, thoughts after.

Rank Team Agg Rank CFP Prob Change
1  Ohio State 1 81.59% 15.8%
2  Clemson 4 66.25% -10.2%
3  Alabama 2 49.19% 0.8%
4  Oklahoma 3 46.39% 8.0%
5  Georgia 5 30.97% -5.1%
6  Penn State 7 30.20% 12.8%
7  LSU 6 26.14% -3.0%
8  Auburn 8 24.69% 8.1%
9  Wisconsin 10 10.71% -16.4%
10  Oregon 9 8.34% -3.4%
11  Washington 13 6.35% 1.0%
12  Florida 12 6.34% -1.6%
13  Notre Dame 11 5.60% -4.5%
14  Wake Forest 43 2.17% -0.2%
15  Iowa 19 1.66% 0.3%
16  Utah 21 0.97% 0.3%
17  Texas 16 0.52% -0.4%
18  Oklahoma State 22 0.42% 0.1%
19  Michigan 15 0.36% 0.1%
20  Michigan State 14 0.26% 0.0%
21  Minnesota 41 0.14% 0.0%
22  Virginia 38 0.14% -0.6%
23  Boise State 36 0.13% -0.2%
24  Baylor 29 0.12% 0.1%
25  Duke 37 0.08% 0.1%
26  Arizona State 33 0.07% 0.0%
27  SMU 34 0.04% 0.0%
28  Kansas State 31 0.03% -0.7%
29  TCU 26 0.02% 0.0%
30  Memphis 35 0.02% 0.0%
31  Miami (FL) 28 0.02% 0.0%
32  California 48 0.01% -0.5%
33  USC 24 0.01% -0.2%
34  Appalachian State 53 0.01% 0.0%
35  Syracuse 64 0.01% 0.0%
36  Mississippi State 25 0.01% -0.3%
37  Texas A&M 20 0.01% 0.0%
38  Iowa State 23 0.00% -0.1%
39  Florida State 39 0.00% 0.0%
40  Pitt 59 0.00% 0.0%
41  Washington State 30 0.00% -0.1%
42  Indiana 40 0.00% 0.0%
43  Arizona 47 0.00% 0.0%
44  Maryland 50 0.00% -0.1%
45  Colorado 54 0.00% 0.0%
46  North Carolina State 66 0.00% 0.0%
47  West Virginia 65 0.00% 0.0%
48  Nebraska 44 0.00% 0.0%
49  Virginia Tech 84 0.00% 0.0%
50  Texas Tech 51 0.00% 0.0%
51  Boston College 83 0.00% 0.0%
52  Louisville 63 0.00% 0.0%
53  Illinois 86 0.00% 0.0%

1.  In a weekend with an even mix of blowouts and close wins amongst the top teams, almost every significant shift in the Playoffs odds can be explained by the teams' week 5 margin of victory.  Ohio State and Penn State won big and climbed up.  Clemson and Wisconsin struggled and fell.  The only real exception to this was Notre Dame, whose win over a decent Virginia team was roughly as big as it should have been.  The Irish's decline is instead because of 1) an ever-weakening strength of schedule and 2) all the other good teams winning, which lessens the chance of an 11-1 team with a weak resume sneaking into the Playoff.

2.  A lot of mediocre to bad power conference teams lost their third game this week.  Kentucky, North Carolina, Ole Miss, Northwestern, Arkansas, Rutgers, Kansas, Purdue, Georgia Tech, Oregon State, UAB, and Navy have all disappeared from the Playoff odds.  The ugliness of this group of eliminations belies just how orderly of a year 2019 has been as still only three top-40 computer teams (#18 UCF, #27 South Carolina, and #32 Cincinnati) have been eliminated.

3.  The conference races are far less orderly.  The ACC Coastal is a complete toss-up with Miami (20%) and UNC (16%) still in the thick of it as well.  SMU (!) and Hawaii (!!!) now lead their respective divisions.  Utah, who is technically tied for last in the standings, is once again the favorite in the Pac 12 South.  And this Friday's UCF-Cincy game will likely be the pivotal battle in an otherwise awful American East.

Conference Favorite Perc   Runner-Up Perc
ACCA Clemson 96.6%   Wake Forest 2.1%
ACCC Virginia 34.9%   Duke 25.8%
AMEE Central Florida 69.0%   Cincinnati 29.1%
AMEW SMU 42.1%   Memphis 35.1%
B10E Ohio State 78.3%   Penn State 18.2%
B10W Wisconsin 69.0%   Iowa 23.1%
B12 Oklahoma 92.2%   Texas 48.5%
CUSAE Florida Atlantic 58.4%   Marshall 24.4%
CUSAW North Texas 39.2%   Southern Miss 30.6%
MACE Ohio 43.1%   Miami (OH) 33.5%
MACW Toledo 46.6%   Western Michigan 38.9%
MWCW Hawaii 42.5%   Fresno State 29.3%
MWCM Boise State 52.2%   Utah State 37.2%
P12N Oregon 69.8%   Washington 28.9%
P12S Utah 43.7%   USC 36.0%
SECE Georgia 76.5%   Florida 22.3%
SECW Alabama 66.4%   LSU 17.9%
SUNE Appalachian State 88.0%   Troy 7.6%
SUNW Louisiana-Lafayette 60.2%   Arkansas State 37.2%


Week 6 Preview

Home Away Home Win Prob Playoff Teams Lost
Florida Auburn 44.1% 0.048
Ohio State Michigan State 90.6% 0.027
Tennessee Georgia 7.4% 0.008
LSU Utah State 92.7% 0.006
Stanford Washington 18.4% 0.006
Michigan Iowa 58.8% 0.004
Oregon California 90.9% 0.004
Penn State Purdue 96.7% 0.003
Kansas Oklahoma 1.8% 0.003
Wisconsin Kent State 98.3% 0.001

A pretty good top two next week, and then....not a lot.  I suppose it might be "interesting" to see if Michigan can continue its rebound against an actually competent team.  Or maybe Stanford or Tennessee will finally live up to their potential.  And Oregon-Cal could be fun if you like defense and hate points.  Worry not, though...the season gets relentlessly exciting after this.